I know you all like stories, so here is one for you.
I've been bi-curious as long as I can remember. Used to try on mom's underwear when home alone as a kid. Penetrated myself with various objects and substances. This continued into my adult life. I am now early thirties and got out of my last relationship (all have been hetero). I've always fantasized about m/m even when in relationships... Moved to a new town and figured it was time to try stuff.
Met a patient guy online and he seemed game for going at my pace.
He was house sitting and I went over to visit him after work. I got myself cleaned up, shaved myself completely as I do when getting ready just in case things went that direction.
My goal was to just be around a guy while naked and see what it felt like. Go from there. No expectations and he was totally cool about that in advance.
I show up at his place, come in, he's waiting for me downstairs, take off my shoes and we go sit on the couch.
I'm super self conscious about my appearance. I'm fit but kinda masc which doesn't mesh with my self perception as a sub bottom (at least that's what I think I am/would be).
Anyway I'm extremely horny just sitting on the couch talking with this guy and he comments on my very obvious erection. I elect to suggest we get naked so I can see what it feels like. He obliges and we are now sitting naked on the couch.
He lives alone and it's the weekend ahead... This could go places and I'm freaking the fuck out mentally.
I can't believe I'm doing this.
I look over and can't take my eyes off his extremely thick cock. My first thought is that there is no possible way that is going to fit in my mouth. Seriously it was almost the diameter of a coke can and a little longer.
I'm aching to do something. He offers to let me touch it which I do. It felt warm and hard. He flexed it a couple times and it felt very different. It took me aback. I started stroking him and here's where things get ...off...
I don't know if it was nerves alone but I'm sure that was a big part of it. I hesitated to do anything more than rub hia dick. I lubricated my hand with spit (left hand, I'm right handed but he was on my left, that didn't help) but it was not getting him off. I think the lack of initial response from him was part of it, almost like a discouragement that I wasn't good at this, was part of it.
The combination of self consciousness, the fact that he looked kinda like a former boss, the fact that his dick was too thick and a tad shorter than mine, and the fact that he wanted to touch my dick (which went against my idea that I would be servicing him and didn't want any kind of recip/touching) all contributed to some kind of turnoff or something. Hard to explain. I let my reservations get the better of me and halted the experience then and there. I felt bad getting that far and stopping, kind a dick move.
He was apologetic and super nice about it. My reaction after the fact was to embrace my hetero persona, got a new gym membership and a workout plan. Hetero dating apps.
Fast forward a month or more and here I am again. I gave up masturbating almost a week ago and my horniness has increase dramatically, which in turn has brought back these urges to explore bi. I used to jack off daily and it kept the urge down but I read it can help work out gains and other things to abstain.
Is my normal state bisexual and I'm just suppressing it by masturbating? Should I try again with this guy or another guy? I can't help but think my expectations are sky high and that I'll be let down and regret trying it, and develop self hatred if I don't like it. I'm lost once again.
Don't mean for this to take a sad turn and am genuinely curious about what I can do. It's weird, it didn't feel like "me" or "something I would do" when I was with the guy. I've masturbated to the whole experience numerous times and fantasized about how things could have gone better.
Anyway thanks for reading, advice is very welcome.
Bookmarks